Comment on: "Borgia A., Mazzoldi A., Brunori C.A., Allocca C., Delcroix C., Micheli L., Vercellino A., Grieco, G., 2014. Volcanic spreading forcing and feedback in geothermal reservoir development,Amiata Volcano,Italia. J. Volc. Geoth. Res. 284, 16-31

Borgia et al. (2014) illustrated an active volcanic spreading model for the Amiata volcanic area (southern Tuscany, Italy). Although, at first glance, the model may appear appealing, this is not fully supported by the available data and the paper does not take into account their discussion. Accordingly, the supposed negative consequences of the Borgia et al. (2014) model on both contamination of shallow water and geothermal exploitation can likely be regarded as speculative.